Wednesday, June 29, 2016

I Broke my fast Today. Secretly in the Bathroom...


I broke my fast today. Secretly in the bathroom by eating candy. I don't even know why I am fasting when I am faking my prayers and don't even really  believe in Islam anymore. I am at the phase where I am questioning Islam watching videos of ex muslims and discovered  a side of islam that is not taught to us and found cherry picked about 'religion of peace' and mercy to mankind but I feel free when I am not caging my own mind.

I thought shaitaan was leading me astray by making me doubt Muhammad 's character etc.. so I tried to resist and it was/is taking a toll on my mental health. I am reading the quran randomly and in one line Allah is cursing a non believer and the next say he is the most merciful — and this is just random, not an active search for contradiction. 

My mind and "heart" still rebel when I dislike or question something. I tell myself a scholar can explain this... and people who criticise  islam (idea) are bigots etc  (more like, people make u feel that u are evil for not seeing  the "beauty & eloquence" of the quran and tell you that doubts are from satan). 

I was reading ur article on menstruation /quran and my mind knew it didn’t make sense but I couldn't  accept the whole of it and my mind was like "there is probably a good explanation and allah is wise and menstruation is dirty" because we have been indoctrinated  since birth (I am a Pashtun Pakistani American by the way ) and I realize how toxic this way of thinking is. I think of myself, ME as dirty and I just am tired of defending statements  like "Islam empowers women"  and much more like wife beating (*sorry light beating* sarcasm). 

My question is how do you start unlearning how to see the world without the lens of islam? I know this email was long but I want someone  to talk to and everyone around me is a Muslim who supports 'death for apostasy' (but in a true Islamic  state of course they are make sure to point out and I am just sitting  there like "what?") And if they found I am no longer a "true beliver" idk what will happen so I want to give you sincere thnx for having this and the comfort of knowing that they are a people who left and I can someday too *Inshallah (*wrote it out of habit so I decided to keep it) 

So a sincere Thank You from a closeted questioning muslimah  


Dear Questioning Muslimah,

My heart goes out to you. What a struggle you must be facing this Ramadan. Its an especially hard time of year for questioning or ex-muslims. Please know that you are not alone. There are many others in your position, only now investigating things that have been deeply ingrained since childhood. It's not easy, but it is possible - and you're definitely on track for it to happen. The first thing to do is ask questions, look for answers... and don't settle for unsatisfactory ones.

I am honoured that one of my blogposts could help that questioning process along, even a little. Yes, its hard and your instinct will be to shut down critical thinking, because you've been told it's wrong and the work of 'shaitaan' since the beginning. Power through that feeling, keep looking for answers, and watch all that unlearning come naturally. It's a gradual process, but the more you read up, and scrutinize - the more layers you'll shed, the more free you'll feel.

Read, watch and listen to alternative perspectives. I'm glad you're looking into ex-muslim views. Because they have been where you are now. With the internet, we have so much information available to us, it's harder for people to teach us cherry picked versions of Islam. Just be careful, if your family is the type that would look up your search history.

I don't quite know how liberal or illiberal your family is, on the wide spectrum of what being 'muslim' means, but if they support death for apostasy that is worrying. I'd make sure to keep my views to myself at least till it's time to move away, for work, uni - something?

Be patient with yourself, don't worry if you still feel like saying a dua before eating or sleeping...small steps. Just let it unfold organically...don't pressure yourself...the occasional inshallah, alhamdulillah will come big deal. I still say those words...more facetiously now than anything... but i do enjoy retaining parts of the culture that I grew up with. I love arabic calligraphy (even religious)  - i think it's breathtakingly beautiful... I don't fast but occasionally i'll enjoy iftar with my family, I celebrate one can retain parts of their old identity and even reconcile them with being an ex or questioning muslim. Some traditions, sights, sounds, words.... are lovely to hold on to if you take the religious conviction out from behind them. Then they are just remnants of our past, that hold no power over us....they are part of our story.

Good luck to you!


Thanks to my wonderful Patrons for their generosity and kindness. 

I’d like to thank Hunter, Rollin, Sean, Charles, David, Kyle, Eric, Stewart, Matthew, Avraham, Kalyan, Corey, Pier, Thomas and Alisa for being the newest contributors to my Patreon. Your support is much, much appreciated! xx

Please consider supporting my work here


  1. ur entire blog is u trying to suck up to white ppl, to try an become one of them, to gain their praise and acceptance, to be one with them. lol, theres A LOT wrong with you.

    1. Thank you for your insightful feedback. Sad that u think critiquing the obvious problems in my own culture and hoping to better them is for the benefit of anyone other than my own community.

      Shortsighted, with low expectations. Sad.. this is why we don't get too far.

  2. More power to you, I went from questioning to having no doubt that all religion is man made.
    I heard you Skyped at the noncon
    I'll give it a listen tonight :)

  3. And then again Islam does not promote violence but it tells you on various occassions that killing a man is equal to killing whole humanity.similarly the rights of woman and other things which are carried out wrongly shoudntmake you question the word of god.Its like you are in a hurry to change your views or convert just because someone somewhere is doing bad deeds in the name of islam and you think oh islam is such a bad religion.How can a sensible person make a judgement without trying to know..Dont follow islam because your parents did,search on your own until your doubts have gone,each of them.Ask literary people who are working for it.And then make a decision.We humans are very capable of reading and interpreting stuff according to our way of thinking.Go out ask and then decide rather then doing nothing and forming an idea and thinking of yourself as very wise to have found an error and settle for it.Again Allah who gave you this wisdom,who put it into your mind,had he not given it to you would you have been able to come up with the things you come up with now? Are you nicemangoes capable of creating a brain and putting wisdom in someones mind.Do it once and il believe every word you tell is right :) come on

    1. oh fuck right off with your selective quotes... islam explicitly condones violence... in fact u read the one u are referring to in context.. you will see that is not the extent of the message. Who do you think you're fooling? And how condescending of u to assume i've just seen some ISIS atrocities and hurriedly converted out of islam. I have spent half my life looking for answers.. examining scripture... seems like from your ignorant comment that I actually know the scripture better than you do. Perhaps you should read up on what you're endorsing rather than believe the lies you're told... and believe the selectively curated hadith and Quran verses you're shown.

      As you said, you condescending douchebag ... "how can a sensible person make judgement without trying to know" read your bloody scripture and try to make sense of the slavery, violence and misogyny....anyone with a rational mind cannot defend it.

      I'm not claiming to be a god, you idiot.. so u can stop waiting for me to create a brain. Anything u can't explain... and if u can't understand how humans are made.. you automatically attribute it to your imaginary sky friend... its like dealing with a child.

  4. Listen to zakir naik or any other scholar.They got enough time to reason with you and put away your doubts with what quran says.Take all your time and find out.May Allah bless you all :)

    1. The Zakir Naik who says he supports osama bin laden and thinks that every muslim should be a terrorist? Well done...u really proved your point there.

      And fuck off with your condescending may allah bless you BS... u dont even have the decency to respect ppls disbelief in signing off a comment... i dread to think how disrespectful you are in your day to day interactions. Imagine non believers greeted you with a hail Satan?